Geoffrey is slain for the a biking collision inside the 1186 and you may Constance partnered (2) Ranulph de Blundeville, cuatro th Earl out-of Chester, into the step 3 rd March 1188, into the a marriage developed by Queen Henry 11. It wedding deteriorated and Ranulph imprisoned Constance during the 1196. Rebellions was basically stimulated across the Brittany on the and you can Ranulph put out their particular in the 1198. Into Brittany, Constance got their unique relationship annulled and later within the 1198, she took Man de Tours just like the her ‘second’ spouse.
Constance passed away old forty, (possibly out of leprosy, maybe following childbirth in order to twin girls) to your 5 th Sep 1201 at the Nantes
Although this wasn’t an effective consanguineous dating but among attraction, people basic-degree relationship would have rendered marriage between Constance and you may any of John’s brothers hopeless rather than good dispensation –– which considering the party’s rating will have needed to are from the new pope himself
The concept you to definitely Constance got an affair that have John pursuing the death of Geoffrey and before John’s marriage so you can Isabella regarding Gloucester in the 1189, and therefore she try mommy to help you Joanna is really contentious and have provoked far dialogue in this genealogical circles.
You to review from a good genealogist claims one ‘the fresh log ‘New Plantagenet Connection’ have penned a keen ahnentafel out of Age Plantagenet, spouse out of Henry V11, that gives Joanna’s mother’s title because the Constance (maybe misnamed Clemence?), Duchess off Brittany. Here is the Constance who had been John’s sis-in-legislation! Considering the well-known animosity between John and you will Constance along with her own tries to push their unique child Arthur’s passion in terms of the fresh throne off England is actually concerned (therefore all know the way disastrously that turned out!), I absolutely discover advised matchmaking a small difficult to consume. The brand new Constance one records illustrates does not hit me personally because the towards the who John can potentially coerce to the sleep.’
‘ A concept who would identify Joanna’s mommy since Constance does not account for a very vital part of canon laws. Who mean that certain trace of matter need seriously attended down seriously to us, in the event it inside it the newest obtain they, the brand new deliberations, or even the genuine dispensation in itself. As much as i are aware, little of your own type can be obtained.’
From the just that have sex having John, not to mention affect him an infant, Constance would have dependent a first-education relationship out-of affinity with all of John’s siblings –– as well as John’s sister Geoffrey
My own personal view for just what it’s value, is the fact got cute Formosa girls Constance started the mother from Joanna she would surely has introduced their particular up within her domestic and her title could well be as well labeled as Constance’s other pupils of the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Fair Maid out of Brittany, Matilda/Maud of Brittany and you will Arthur).
Agatha was born regarding 1168 into the Chartley Palace, Staffordshire. It’s infamous one she was a domme off John and lots of family trees provide her, even when solitary, once the mommy from Joanna. Very genealogists yet not are convinced that it’s just supposition you to definitely the woman is Joanna’s mom given that no facts otherwise records can be found to demonstrate it.
You to supply apparently given was Sir William Dugdale, from the Baronage from England (1675-6). He states his provider are Dr David Howell’s ‘Reputation of Wales’ (1584). Powell’s tasks are an expanded edition away from H Lloyd’s translation off ‘The newest Historie away from Cambria’ of the 12 th century Saint Caradoc from Llancarfan. An alternate origin, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ of the Charles Browning, copyright 1969 also names Agatha de- Ferrers, daughter regarding Robert de Ferrers, next Earl off derby, while the Joanna’s mommy.
Even if she can’t be entirely overlooked since a candidate to possess mom of Joanna, undoubtedly there is particular shade away from their own in a good chronicle or other historic reference, in the event the she had actually started the mother of one’s wife of the new Prince out of North Wales.